Signs direct people towards tax help in the Iowa City public library on Wednesday, Feb. 15, 2017. UI law students provide the free tax service to community members. (The Daily Iowan/Joseph Cress)

Guest opinion: GOP’s tax cut proposal promises eventual tax increases


Tax cuts are historically followed by personal tax increases—so don’t believe the GOP hype.

America’s Republican-controlled Congress promises its proposed tax cut plan will pay for itself through economic growth. This assertion lacks any historical precedent.

No politician of any stripe has admitted, or ever will admit, that tax cuts are always followed by tax increases. Presidents John F. Kennedy (Democrat) and Lyndon Johnson (Democrat) reduced taxes in 1962 and 1964; taxes were raised in 1966 and 1968. In 1981, President Ronald Reagan (Republican) lowered taxes, and they were increased in 1982, 1983, and 1984. President George W. Bush (Republican) enacted tax cuts in 2001 and 2003; taxes were increased in 2013.

Who pays for the inevitable increased taxes? It never has been placed on the back of corporations. You and I will be saddled with paying more taxes. Knowing this fact, Congress needs to give serious attention to a more grandiose problem than its current smoke and mirrors tax plan.

The current GOP tax proposal will add, according to the Congressional Budget Office, $1.7 trillion to our already out-of-control fiscal debt, currently $20.4 trillion. To put this number into perspective, each child, teenager, and adult must pony up $63,000 to erase our debt, an increase of $3,000 from last year.

Our public debt equals 77 percent of America’s gross domestic product. Economists note when our debt gets to 90 percent of GDP, our financial status will be equivalent to bankrupt Argentina, Belarus, Belize, Greece, Jamaica, Ukraine, and Venezuela.

RELATED: Guest Opinion: Reject Republican tax plan

Why should Iowans care about the debt? Thirty-three percent of Iowa’s $22.7 billion total budget comes from Uncle Sam. Unless Congress gets its act together and puts federal deficit control before tax reformation, Iowa will receive fewer federal resources for important issues like transportation, education, Medicaid, energy efficiency projects, nutritional programs, city revitalization, and child welfare services, to name a few.

None of our previous 44 presidents can be blamed for our debt problem. Why? The federal budget is established by the U.S. House and Senate, not the president’s office. The real culprits for our ugly predicament include all senators and representatives elected since 1974 who have approved out-of-control spending. This includes Sens. Grassley and Ernst and Reps. Blum, King, Loebsack, and Young; their 10 percent approval rating is proper.

Without budget discipline by Congress, America will have a Value Added Tax, higher interest rates, uncontrolled inflation, decline of private investments, and slower economic growth.

Before enacting any tax package, Congress must first focus on our deficit and do two things:

First, support the Fiscal Responsibility Act, which prohibits Congress from passing budgets that would increase the national debt as a share of the overall economy, except in cases of war, disaster, or recession. FYI: 76 percent of Democrats, 87 percent of Republicans, and 78 percent of independents support this initiative, according to Cohen Research Group.

RELATED: Iowa City prepared for tax losses if need be 

Second, support the No Budget-No Pay Act, whereby if the spending appropriations process is not completed by the start of a new federal fiscal year, congressional pay ceases as of Oct. 1 and salaries are not restored until the appropriations is completed. FYI: 82 percent of Republicans and Democrats and 79 percent of independents support No Budget, No Pay, according to Cohen Research Group.

If our 535 elected representatives to Washington would enact these two measures, we could rein in our public debt and then Congress could propose a well-thought-out tax plan. Unfortunately, our lawmakers have ignored our federal debt and tax history, putting the cart before the horse.

Knowing you are now being hoodwinked by the promise of a tax cut, don’t act dumbfounded when your personal taxes increase. Without controlling our $20.4 trillion federal debt, tax cuts followed by tax increases will occur — guaranteed.

— Steve Corbin
Professor Emeritus of Marketing
University of Northern Iowa

Special Sections

Print Edition

Front Page PDF

Text Links